Privacy-Focused Alternative to Google Widevine DRM for Protected Content Playback

I wanted to suggest to develop or integrate a privacy-respecting alternative to Google Widevine for DRM-protected content playback (Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video, etc.). Getting rid of this google slop monopoly that put your privacy at risk.

@CapitanKriger There are only three types of DRM for the most part

  • Widevine = Google
  • PlayReady = Microsoft
  • FairPlay = Apple

PlayReady has long been tied to the OS and generally only available for Edge. Lately they expanded out to where it can be used in Chrome, but this is just on Windows 11.

FairPlay is Safari only for Mac and then all browsers on iOS.

Pretty much the only thing left is Widevine.

The main issue:

DRM is not chosen by Brave; it is required by content providers (Netflix, Disney+, etc.) and their licensing deals with movie studios. If Brave created its own “Brave-DRM,” Netflix wouldn’t send their video keys to it because it hasn’t been “vetted” by the studios to ensure the video can’t be easily copied.

The only way to truly get rid of the “Google slop monopoly” is for the industry to move toward an open standard like EME (Encrypted Media Extensions) that allows for “stateless” or “anonymous” license requests. Unfortunately, we aren’t there yet.

-NOTE-

Widevine doesn’t collect your data or anything. It does provide a unique identifier to sites when used. But you can resolve that by only using it when you need it or by having its own profile.

I was about to just write this.

I’d like to add too, that for a time (unless it’s still a limitation), Microsoft’s PlayReady only works in their specific PWA’s, like the Netflix “app” on Windows, which really is an Edge PWA but does not once look like a normal PWA, but does use PlayReady (hence the 4k ability on Windows), but if you use Edge in the browser and Brave, suddenly that same Netflix stream is 1080p tops.

(Though, PlayReady might work in Edge now without needing a PWA, since you mentioned it being expanded out to be used in Chrome, which would have been that requirement to work in Edge without their “special” PWA.)

@MasterLink I was seeing from things like:

https://windowsforum.com/threads/chrome-to-support-playready-drm-on-windows-11-for-enhanced-4k-streaming.374649/

And AI was saying it’s available within these flags, which in turn allow for 4k which otherwise might not be available via Widevine. But I am dumb when it comes to these things and need to learn more about it later.

https://docs.axinom.com/blog/hardware-drm-chrome-windows#:~:text=It%20may%20come%20as%20a%20surprise%20but,with%20version%20142%2C%20Chrome%20supports%20PlayReady%20Security

Actually, @Mattches or @steeven, I’m going to tag you both on this to see if you can help on clarification. Especially as I’m seeing those flags enabled by default on my version of Brave. Curious about the overall interaction.

I’m admittedly not up to date on the DRM stuff much, it’s gotten so complex and beyond even me that I had to give up. The licensing is so ridiculous as it is.

@Saoiray sorry, I’m a bit confused here – what is the exact question you have?

Basically if one DRM engine can be swapped for another open source alternative away from Google Widevine.

But I don’t see it happening, as was mentioned it would be lacking the right keys and licensing. I believe they were just asking for clarification on that part since admittedly DRM stuff is confusing beyond belief at this point.\

(I mean shoot, I have a UHD Bluray drive on my PC, but being an AMD user, I have to “LibreDrive” firmware mod my drive to make the movies play because AMD never got the SGX instruction, and even new Intel’s don’t either. So I’ve been on that side of DRM nightmares.)

@Mattches So I was shifting a bit compared to OP, but staying related. The links I shared showed that Chromium was able to now use Microsoft’s PlayReady for DRM. This would allow for 4k streaming, which supposedly isn’t done with Widevine.

To enable, it said to turn on the flags for Hardware Secure Decryption.

I am assuming Brave has inherited this from Chromium but not sure how it all works. I’m looking for confirmation if it is indeed tied in with PlayReady, especially as I was seeing the flags enabled by default.

I was also questioning if devs were tracking this for Brave, particularly since it’s an upstream change. And depending on answers , whether this will also have a toggle in settings similar to how Widevine is established or if it just relies on flags.

But regardless, just want to confirm if I’m reading it all properly and to understand if the integration is there (at least for Windows 11)

Along with that am trying to fully understand the usefulness and privacy implications as touched on from data in screenshots below.

Along with supposed privacy aspect: