The BAT icon (triangle in the address bar) doesn’t show the blue checkmark when I visit verified authors such as brave.com wikipedia.org etc. (Brave 1.19.92, Windows 10)
same problem . 
@steeven same problem
@sriram please help us
(Brave 1.19.92 Windows 10)
I’ve noticed that the triangle starts working properly after one click. To recap: without doing anything, the triangle never shows the blue checkmark (which is a bug). After clicking the triangle, preferably in a verified author’s website, the triangle will show the blue checkmark while visiting every next verified website.
@fmarier might be interested in this bug